Showing posts with label Jewish Community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jewish Community. Show all posts

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Intermarriage, Divorce, and the "Great Jewish-American Wealth Transfer"

The deluge of divorce and intermarriage sweeping across the Jewish-American landscape has and will continue to impact the Jewish-American community in unforeseen ways.

No, I am not referring solely to the loss of half of our children to marriages where Jewish values, culture, and history are not passed on. Nor do I refer merely to the drop in numbers of Jewish children born due to the accelerating epidemic of single life propagated by the likes of Huffingtonpost.com. Instead I am referring to the transfer of wealth from the hands of hard working and entrepreneurial Americans who identify themselves as Jews, to the hands of others who do not.

The real consequences of this trend are already being felt. In a recent survey of the most philanthropic in America, Jews, unsurprisingly, held five of the top six spots, and there were 19 Jews amongst the top 53
(http://www.jewishjournal.org/story/news_features/survey_finds_jews_are_top_givers_in_the_u.s/). Yet most of their charity was directed at non-Jewish causes. This is, in itself, not a bad thing. After all, Jews have always contributed to larger society and such contributions are considered central to Torah-true living. On the other hand, the upkeep of Jewish institutions is a prerequisite to maintaining Jewish tradition and heritage. Day schools, hospitals, museums, houses of prayer, political action , kosher food, mikvahs (ritual baths), soup kitchens, medical assistance etc. are all expensive enterprises that have historically been considered the collective responsibility of every Jew, each according to their means (Jews are required to give 10 percent of their earning to charity, on top of taxes).

There is a long standing Jewish tradition of philanthropy. The 19th and early 20th century Rothschilds have been replaced by the 21st century Lev Levaivs. The biblical tabernacle built in the dessert, the two temples of Jerusalem, and almost every single past and present Jewish institution was funded by Jews who stepped up to the plate and continued the historic use of Jewish wealth to benefit the global Jewish community.

Until now.

For the first time since the era of Ezra and Nechemya (the end of Babylonian/Persian exile) assimilation and divorce has become the norm in the Jewish diaspora. This new norm has in-turn impacted the entire Jewish community in unforeseen ways.

Jews are disproportionally wealthy and, in most cases, happily shoulder the burden of corollary taxation. However, public schools, fast food, and churches do not assist the Jewish community in passing on 3000 year old traditions. Many Jews pay for public schools but send their children to private schools; Jews don’t eat cheap fast food, but pay close to double for (often equally unhealthy) kosher food. Jews close their businesses on the busiest consumer day of the week. Despite all the above challenges the Jewish community has committed itself -for over 2000 years with little complaint and out of love and devotion- to propagating Jewish tradition.

Every intermarriage that ends in divorce or results in offspring who eschew Jewish tradition engenders an unquantifiable, and often undesired, transfer of wealth from Jewish hands. The ramifications are felt across the nation and globe, and have been further compounded by the general economic malaise. Many Jews turned their back on their secular coreligionists, but that was wrong both from a humanitarian perspective and from a Jewish-legal viewpoint (Rabbi Hillel said “love your neighbor like yourself, this is the great law of the Torah”), and now the tangible economic implications are clear. Jews continue to be leading philanthropists, but many Jews are unable to educate and pass on their traditions. Many Jews eat only Kosher, so they don’t buy meat which they can’t afford. Many houses of prayer and study-halls (Beit Knesset, Beit medrash) want to provide a relaxing and comfortable milieu for prayer and study but they close their doors do to the lack of funds.

Where is all that famous Jewish wealth? Just look at the wonderful New York Philharmonic and billion dollar endowments of Harvard and Yale.

Yes this is a free and integrated country, yes all have a fundamental right to choose their own destiny, and yes Jews are not required by secular law to provide for their brothers and sisters. But the Jewish community should at least be made aware of the implications of the continued failure to educate and pass on our millennia old tradition to the next generation. Our failure translates into the continued transfer of Jewish wealth into the hands of others -from Jewish synagogues and schools to libraries and universities. This is not just about losing a generation of "other" Jewish children, this is about our own children!

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Separate Housing: With All Due Respect I Must Object to the Rabbis Position

One of the most unappreciated ramifications of European ghetto laws was that instead of leading to assimilation and conversion they perpetuated Orthodox Judaism. Yes that’s right, by prohibiting Jews from mingling with their gentile neighbors the state and church helped ensure strong and homogenous Jewish communities that are the antecedents of present world Jewry. The extraordinary advantages that these ghetto communities engendered were not lost on the Jewish faithful. Today nearly every city with a large Jewish population includes a segment of that Jewish demographic that chooses to reinvent the ghetto atmosphere. Precisely because its enables strong centralization of Jewish authority which is, they claim, a prerequisite for high levels of conformity to orthodox Jewish life.

Ironically, for the first time in the history of the Jewish Diasporas a minority of Israeli Rabbis are embracing a logic similar to that used by their European oppressors. Don’t get me wrong, the European gentiles were not faced with terror or the threat of assimilation -Judaism is not easy, and Jews don’t voluntarily blow children up (please see “Understanding the Goldstone Report: Intentions vs. Results”, if you find this assertion interesting). Conversely, Jews have a history of assimilation and Arabs a history of terror.

Still, Israeli Rabbis should not ignore the historical results of this logic. Remember, when the gentiles coerced separation, the result was a resilient Jewish community, and one that was prevented from contributing (their loss!). On the other hand, here in the states, some Jews have embraced the melting-pot ethos and completely assimilated into larger American society. Others have embraced the more modern notion of multi-culture America and have completely maintained their Jewish identity. Regardless most are overwhelmingly loyal citizens who contribute in every way to American society.

So I must ask: are the Israeli Rabbis implying that Arab-Israelis cannot do the same?

Yes I know that America has friendly relations with Israel, and that contributes to Jewish-American loyalty. But Jews in Iran are loyal to Iran despite Iran’s track-record vis-à-vis Israel. The same can be said regarding Jews in Britain, France, Brazil, and Turkey despite their, often, hostile stance towards Israel. My point is simple; just because Israeli-Arabs have reason to be disloyal does not mean that they are inherently disloyal.

I also know that many Israeli-Arabs are disloyal and often involved in the vilest anti-Israeli activities. But even if most Israeli-Arabs oppose Israeli treatment of Arabs in Gaza and the West-bank -and vocalize their opposition to that end-, they do so within the confines of Israeli law. Americans are renowned for vocalizing their extreme opposition to leaders and many American celebrities visit America's enemies (Michael Moore, Carter, Oliver Stone…all incidentally are often associated with antisemitism), but they are not discriminated against and nor should they be.

Yes, if Israeli-Arabs violate the law they should be prosecuted. Yes, I believe in a certain degree of profiling in Israel and abroad. Yes, Israeli-Arabs have yet to contribute in any meaningful way to the success of their host state. Yes, the Rabbis have every right to express their position. Indeed, the notion that separating Jew from Arab will protect Jews from terror, assimilation, and moral decay, may have some merit. But separate housing will never prevent the above from occurring, just look at the Jewish ghettos that spot New York and Jerusalem. Are they free of Arab terror, or of assimilation, or of moral depravity?!

We know that in a fair society true social cohesion is possible. I believe Israel is such a society. Therefore, with all due respect, I must object to the Rabbis’ position.

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

A Muslim Questions: "Another Verbal Bomb from Rabbi Ovadia Yosef"

Jpost reported
http://www.jpost.com/JewishWorld/JewishNews/Article.aspx?ID=191782&R=R1&utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter

that Rabbi Ovadia Yoesef, former Sephardic Chief Rabbi of Israel and spiritual leader of the Shas party, declared that

“Goyim were born only to serve us. Without that, they have no place in the world – only to serve the People of Israel,” (context: he said this in his weekly Saturday night sermon on the laws regarding the actions non-Jews are permitted to perform on Shabbat).

and

“In Israel, death has no dominion over them... With gentiles, it will be like any person – they need to die, but [God] will give them longevity. Why? Imagine that one’s donkey would die, they’d lose their money.

and

This is his servant... That’s why he gets a long life, to work well for this Jew,” Yosef said.

and

“Why are gentiles needed? They will work, they will plow, they will reap. We will sit like an effendi and eat."

My Muslim friend emailed me with the news and asked:

"Did he really say this? If so, this schmuck really isn't helping Israel's cause. I know that there are a lot of websites out there that love to cherry pick verses from the Talmud and Torah in order to show how "bad" the Jews are, same way that propagandists do to Islam, but from your perspective, I have to ask. Is there any kind of scriptural justification or reasoning for what this guy is saying?"

My response:
(note: I edited my response for source citing, and clarification)

Another verbal bomb from Rabbi Yosef.

Yes there are such commentaries on Isaiah ("And the strangers shall stand and feed your flocks" Isaiah 61:5) for example, and more recent Rabbinic leaders like Rabbi Kook, are quoted as making similar statements. But those exegesis and statements can only be understood in context of the commentators understanding of divine purpose, i.e. the Jews were to spread the belief in G-d (not Judaism, but G-d) , and the gentiles were to help them do it. The commentators saw the mission of the gentile like our society sees support for higher education. Indeed, the supporters are often seen as MORE important than the average academic (an example but there is much more nuance). The commentators intended a meaningful exposition of divine wisdom. From this article it seems the Rabbi was gratuitously insulting and intentionally speaking out of context.

I believe that a proper understanding of the concept of the chosen people, offers a concrete scenario whereas the original commentators perspective can be understood. (My blog post http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/03/chosen-people-what-does-it-mean.html, as well as http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jews_as_a_chosen_people discusses this in depth). In short we are all servants/messengers of G-d. The Rabbi created a hierarchy, but in the eyes of G-d there are not, cannot be, hierarchies. Our greatest Rabbis said, and we repeat it on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur that we are as dust in front of you (G-d), this theme is repeated in Ethics of Our Fathers" (Pirkei Avot) and elsewhere. Indeed the finite (one or one million) is equally insignificant when measured against the infinite.

I would add that Rabbi Yosef has never been seen by the ChaBaD community or most Orthodox-American (never mind the rest of the Jewish-secular Diaspora) Jews as acting to benefit Israel. He supported Oslo, against clear Rabbinic (Maimonides for example, he was opposed by many leading Rabbis, including my Grandfather, Abraham B. Hecht) injunctions that were of utmost relevance. Recently he cursed the Arabs, and retracted...There is no source in Judaism for such a curse.
He cannot speak for the Jewish community not because he is too extreme, but because he repeatedly abrogates Jewish Rabbinic principles.

Still he has a tremendous following amongst Israeli ultra-orthodox Sephardim and he is a true Torah scholar, beyond most anyone I know.

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

An Evolutionary Perspective on Israel Bias in the UN and Endemic Anti-Semitism

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), on the last day of its annual general conference, voted against a non-binding resolution urging Israel to accede to the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).The paper -- which Washington had asked Arab countries not to table at all for fear it could jeopardize a conference on a nuclear weapons-free Middle East to be held in 2012 -- was rejected by the 151-member general assembly with 51 votes against it, 46 votes in favor and 23 abstentions. (http://news.yahoo.com/s/afp/20100924/wl_mideast_afp/iaeanuclearpoliticsisrael).

Why is this news?

Over the last 60 years every apparatus of the United Nations -from the General Assembly (UNGA) to the Human Rights Council (UNHRC, previously the UNCRH )- has served as instruments to channel the international community’s anti-Israel fervor. One egregious example of this long standing trend had the 2010 session of the UNHRC (as of March 25) passing 5 resolutions condemning Israel -more than the total combined amount of resolutions it dedicated to all other countries in the world — one each on Burma, North Korea and Guinea. No mention of Darfur, Tibet, Iran, Syria, Egypt, Russia, Congo, Libya etc.

Some attribute this blatant lopsidedness to the nature of the UN. Namely its various committees, especially the human rights council, are controlled and/or heavily influenced by political blocks. The block with the most votes is that of non-aligned states i.e. most non-Western states. This means, for example, that France may verbally condemn Iranian violations but because it does not want Iran and its allies to vote against Frances interests in the future France abstains from voting for a resolution condemning Iran. Furthermore, because non-aligned states outnumber western states, they can vote any member-state into any commission. For example, Libya, a gross violator of human rights was elected to the UNHRC. But Israel, with its few allies is one state that the world can agree to condemn without fearing any vote related backlash. Indeed condemning Israel is often used to justify the existence of an otherwise inept UN. After all the UN is fighting injustice, just not ALL injustice.

Still others contend that the reason that Israel is so predictably and consistently targeted is because Israel deserves it. In other words, the fact that HAMAS cannot rearm openly, because of Israel’s embargo, and Israel’s often overwhelming defense of its population trumps the wide-spread government sponsored suppression, rape, and murder of UNHRC members like Libya and Iran.

I agree, politics is one factor that contributes to the UN’s track record but there is another.

Yes you guessed correctly, my input relates to anti-Semitism but only so far as anti-Semitism is a label for what evolutionary theory calls natural selection and what others conflate with "survival of the fittest”.

Briefly, natural selection is “the ability of an organism to survive, adapt, and proliferate in its environment” this success is attributed to genetic traits. On the other hand the “survival of the fittest” implies superior fitness/external traits. This difference is key to understanding Hitler’s conception of the uber race, anti-Semitism, and is at the root of the UN’s obsession with condemning Jews/Israel.

Hitler argued that the physical traits of the Aryan, blond hair and such, were evidence of their genetic superiority, whereas Jewish noses, somehow proved genetic inferiority . But Hitler confused the cause and the effect. It is internal genetic traits that enable organisms to thrive -ones hair color and height are the effect of genetic traits not their cause. Thus such external traits cannot serve as evidence of genetic tenacity.

OK, so Hitler confused cause an affect, whats the point?

First a question:

Why did Hitler reach for a genetic reason to condemn Jews, why didn't he focus only on the usual stereotypes?

Because many anti-Semites throughout history made the claim that Jews were inferior. At first it was Jews did not assimilate into the Roman empire. Then Jews refused to convert to Christianity. Then the Jews killed the Jew Jesus. Then the hate was justified by Jewish disloyalty to their host state, and/or the Jewish control of world banks etc...

Hitler assumed that all these Jewish "sins" must reflect a deeper inferiority of the Jew, he proved this by pointing out the Jewish nose and hair color. The irony is that Hitler's reasoning was just as flawed as his predecessors. For he used perceived external traits as evidence of internal flaws. His forbearer's pointed to Jewish stubbornness, Hitler pointed to Jewish physical characteristics

This illogical trend raises an obvious question: why do anti-Semites continually condemn Jews based on external factors like noses and conspiracies to control banks? Can one really make a claim about the innate properties of a people based on external sins? Indeed, can UN nations really sit in judgement of Israel's excessive self-defense while many of its own members rape and murder by the thousands!?

It would seem then that the proclaimed/conscious flawed reasoning of the anti-Semite reflect "survival of the fittest" principles, whereas their true sub-conscious motivations reflect natural selection

Hitler, the anti-Semite, and the UN are all motivated by a similar concern. Namely the unwillingness to accept that their hate is not based on objective external factors like noses, religion, or propensity for economic malfeasance ("survival of the fittest"). Rather it stems from a deeply rooted evolutionary fear that the Jews success, despite everything, is evidence of natural selection working in favor of the Jews.


The UN has simply institutionalized, on a global scale, the irrational fears of the simple anti-Semite.

At first Israel teetered on the edge of a social, political, and existential abyss, but now it has emerged as a small world power. The nations of the world are worried once again. The UN's collective subconscious is crying “evolution is at work the Jews are supplanting us”. The conscious manifestation of this is the inexplicable and abysmal bias against Israel expressed in every corner of the UN and the reemergence of anti-Semitism in every corner of the world.

In short there is reason to believe that evolutionary principles are at the root of all this preponderance of hate by the anti-Semite and in the UN. Caused by overwhelming Jewish success that spans all known history that was, and is, perceived as an existential threat to the ascendency of the non-Jewish species. The manifest result of this perception is labeled "anti-Semitism". The perceived threat of the Jewish "species" was compounded by the failure of the various state-sponsored measures of forced conversion expulsion, and ghettos. Despite every effort the Jew not only survived but prospered. The anti-Semite interpreted this, subconsciously, as evidence of the Jewish evolutionary ascendancy and responded to it consciously by discounting Jewish success as nefarious and ill-gained, -anything to not have to face up to their own insecurities- and then persecuting the Jew.

It seems only natural that the UN manifests this carnal fear of Jewish superiority in its treatment of Israel. As Israel, like the Jew, continues to experience ever greater success despite global efforts of boycott, sanction, condemnation, terror, to force Israel into submission. Yes, the UN has taken on both the deep-seated motivations and misinterpreted manifestations of the anti-Semite. The UN justifies its hate-campaign by pointing to Israel’s wrongs, but the extent and bias of this pointing is at its root a subconscious motivation- the collective fear of Israeli success.

The tragedy is that anti-Semites and the UN continue to make Hitler’s mistake by assuming that external factors such as Jewish success, “survival of the fittest”, is valid evidence of natural selection choosing the Jew. Not only is this a inverted conception of natural selection (as described above), and thus in itself should not arouse the subconscious fear, it is also the Jewish perspective that if natural selection is correct it is in itself a tool of a higher power. It is not the final determinant of survival and success.

The world need not perceive Israel’s successes as a threat, just as the anti-Semite need not perceive the Jew as attempting his dissolution.

On the contrary:

As is evidenced by global Jewry in general and the Jewish-American experience in particular, Jews can and do contribute in every way to society.

Interestingly all the above may explain Americas pro-Israel track-record.

Why is America an exceptional example of Jewish contribution? Because America is a society that is secure in its own inherent worth and is not threatened by a subconscious psychosis that natural selection is favoring the Jew, to the detriment of the rest.

THAT is a major factor contributing to Americas general (though not unanimous) support of Israel in the UN, and Americas/Americans relatively stellar record on anti-Semitism.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

This 9/11: Islam Needs ChaBaD!

Many Muslims, including a close friend, argue that Islam is not violent, suicidal, or expansionist. Yet people like me, see the reality. Homicide bombings, stoning, insult laden mosque building, and little self criticism. Which one is it?

Some of these said acquaintances have concluded that even if some Muslims are genuinely opposed to the hate and pain that their coreligionists cause it is because they are “reform” Muslims or they are afraid of discrimination and would otherwise be quick to support the hate.

I do not agree with this absolute bifurcation. Nor do I not subscribe to the following proposal out of naiveté or even unwarranted optimism –on the contrary as a lover of America and a proud Jew I cannot forgive, nor close my eyes to the unrepentant terror and hate that Islam-inspired extremism has directed against my nation and people. Rather I make the following assertions based on my personal experience with scrupulous orthodox-Muslims who proudly acknowledge that their religion has a violent past and even seeks to convert others, but who are also adamantly opposed to both Sunni motivated Saudi extremism and Shia instigated terror.

Furthermore these same Muslims concede that they -peace and Koran loving Muslims- are not doing enough to fight this real corruption within the ranks of their coreligionists or preventing the insidious/misguided acts by moderate Muslims (such as the ground zero mosque). Then again, they justly contend, they do not have the oil of Iran or Saudi Arabia to propagate their view.

It is to these Muslims that I address the following suggestion:

To be clear I offer this suggestion not as a patronizing snob but as a religious Jew who has seen with my own eyes how ChaBaD, an uncompromising cadre of orthodox Jews who focus on the Jewish believe in unqualified acts of goodness and kindness, has revolutionized and revitalized international Judaism. Not through trying to convince other orthodox streams of Judaism to mimic them but by reaching out to largely secular world Jewry with words of inspiration, lessons in fundamental Jewish practice like charity, "love thy neighbor", acts of goodness and kindness, and heartfelt prayer. This all the while accurately emphasizing that this is not a form of “Judaism-lite” but rather essential practice; a prerequisite to Torah/Rabbinic-true Judaism.

Does this mean that ChaBaD obscures that orthodox Judaism is opposed to same-sex marriage, abortion (under most circumstances), and the expulsion of Jews from parts of Israel? Does it mean that ChaBaD Jews are apolitical and do not have strong, even offensive, personal beliefs? No and no. What it means is that the focus of outreach and study is on the affirmative practice of fundamental Judaism to the best of the individual’s ability.

The upshot is that even the most hard-core ultra-orthodox Jews have recognized the validity of ChaBaD’s efforts and focus, and have themselves been reinvigorated and strengthened in the practice of Jewish principles like love thy neighbor (irrespective of religious practice or background) and general acts of goodness.

I believe that if orthodox Muslims (not easy to dismiss reform/apologist) began a movement that focused on spreading the positive FUNDAMENTALS of Islam to their secular Muslim brothers and sisters -not a watered down presentation offered by “Muslims at heart” but a Koran true message taught by practicing main stream orthodox Muslims that focused on charity, prayer, and belief in their creator- ChaBaD-like results could be achieved.

Likewise, as in the ChaBaD approach, the outreach should not target the hard headed extremists THAT DO GATHER in some mosques and educate the unwary youth regarding all those kaufers (infidels) and how the world is out to destroy Islam. Rather it should focus on secular Muslims; those that know their religion only as it is depicted by Al Jazeera, Memri, Drudgereport, or the New York Times –if at all.

True orthodox Muslims believe that they must proselyte non-Muslims and that defaming the prophet is wrong, but so do Christians. The point is that Muslims can be true to their religion and offer a purely positive message to those around them. The face of Islam need not be defined by incendiary community-center projects, flag burning, or threats against the expression of free speech. On the contrary devout Muslim-Americans who seek what Islam demands –peace- should grasp the opportunity, economic and political, that America offers.

Indeed if you, American-Muslims, gathered to fight extremism through education, the totality of America would put its powerful shoulder to the same wheel and support you to the benefit of all.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Why Every War in The Middle East Weakens the Palestinians

Despite Netanyahu’s unprecedented freeze of all construction in the disputed territories PA/PLO/Fatah leader Abbas refuses to have direct negotiations with Israel demanding that Israel first concede most of what is supposed to be negotiated. Meanwhile Hezbollah/Lebanon attacks an Israeli patrol, which was cutting down a tree, after informing the UN peace-keepers as per the UNSC resolution 1701 agreement. Perhaps trying to deflect attention from the indictment of senior Hezbollah operatives for the 2005 assassination of Lebanese PM Rafik Hariri.

Both of these developments could have happened ten years ago and we wouldn’t have known the difference. At the same time they reveal yet another fallacy in pro-Palestinian thinking.

You see the average Jew on the streets of Paris, London, Madrid, Quebec, Burn, Berlin , Amsterdam etc. knows exactly what to expect during any conflict in the middle east, anti-Semitism, boycotts, media libel, and flag-burning/destructive protests etc. Eventually many Jews decide that they are no longer welcome in these countries, especially the ones which are rapidly filling with Muslim immigrants. Because it is usually those Muslim immigrants who target anything Jewish, and it is the host governments which are faced with the difficult option of integrating Muslims but often find it easier to allow them an avenue to hate, the Jews are a convenient target.

So the hardworking Jew, probably a doctor, scientist, or financial analyst returns home one day perhaps with drying blood/spittle on their shirt, a light injury contributed by the dregs of their society a disaffected Muslim, left wing, or right wins thug. They sit down with their family take of their hat covering/hiding their kippa, and describe how they were jumped on a train full of people by a group of bums shouting “death to Israel” or too “bad Hitler didn’t finish the job” -they tried to defend themselves but there were too many cowards…

Why not move to Israel, there our family will be protected, after all it is one of the most successful countries in the world were Jews are allowed to protect themselves and if there is discrimination is doesn’t target Jews. They move to Israel and help contribute to the latest scientific breakthrough perhaps another Nobel prize!

The above is exactly what is going on all over the Jewish-world Israel is seeing the largest influx of Jews from North America, France and the UK since the 90’s. Never mind the steady flow of Jews from Africa, and Asia. The fact of the matter is that every war in the Middle East increases immigration to Israel, and Israel becomes stronger. The byproduct of this inevitability is that Palestinians and those who encourage their self immolation -most of the power hungry Muslim middle-east, become weaker.

It is ironic considering that that many Palestinians/left-wingers/demographers and one state advocates, believe openly or otherwise that it is just a matter of time before Israel’s Jewish majority devolves into a minority. The argument in their mind is that we can outwait the Jews and in the intern make their lives miserable (as if this somehow encourages ambivalent Jews to accept the notion that if there was no state of Israel they would have equal rights in Palestine!).

Yet what happens if Frances 500,000 plus Jewish community or even a fraction of the Americas 7 million plus Jewish population feels like they need to move to Israel? Let us further postulate that many of these Jews find that the West Bank is really cheap… But further aggressions by Hezbollah and HAMAS, stirred by their masters in Iran is exactly what actualizes the above scenario. And runs contrary to the line of reasoning that supports Abbas’s refusal to negotiate, as war strengthens Israel.

Some with noxious conspirator tendencies (those who are adept at taking a kernel of truth and using it to prove a lie please see post for discussion on this tendency: http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/07/oliver-even-if-jews-do-control-americas.html) conclude that this proves that anti-Semitism is fomented by Israel, or by the ADL. Unlikely, but either way the longer the Palestinians wait to get their act together and give up on their dream of greater Palestine, the more war and thus the smaller their chances of having a land of their own. This is besides the fact that in every war with Israel the arab/muslims always sustain more casualties.

For those who are really pro-Palestinians (not anti-Israel), you would do well to encourage less war and more conversation.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Oliver Even if the Jews Do Control America's Media, If You Had Your Chance...

Oliver thanks for retracting your outrageous comments, “that were anyway taken out of context”. Still your retraction intentionally didn't cover the main offense. You referenced an important issue that many an anti-Semite loves to declare: “the Jews control the media”. Here is some perspective, on your classic display of hate.

You imply that the Jews control the media because…because of what? Your point is that because Jews are disproportionally represented in the media, is in itself evidence that the Jews “control” the media, and that that control was ill gotten?!

This is an interesting strategy, observing a truth, the Jews are disproportionately represented in the media, and then blending a truth with a lie by implying that “disproportionate” equals “illicitly achieved control”, which is a baseless conspiracy. How wise, how subtle, how obvious. The Jew is adept at discerning the hater.

Here is an example. In the 1348-1351s Western Europe was devastated by the bubonic plague, “the black death”. Historians estimate that between one quarter to a half of Western Europe's population perished. The mobs, of course, looked for a scapegoat and discovered a truth: the Jews were less susceptible to the plague. They observed a truth and concluded that the Jews, being less affected, must be responsible for the plague. A rumor spread that the Jews were poisoning the wells, and mobs, egged on by the Stones' (secularists, trying to eliminate Jewish competition), Gibsons' (blood thirsty catholic clergy), and Thomases' (hate filled city officials) of their day, raged in every city, raping, pillaging and killing Jewish men, women, and children. After all, they argued, the truth was that less Jews were dying.

You see what the ignorant masses didn’t know was that Jews were in a constant state of ritual purity. This includes washing their hands before every meal and after every bowl movement. Married Jewish women are required to bathe every 30 days, and Jews in general are advised to bathe on the eve of the Jewish Sabbath. Indeed Jews washed constantly despite the medical view which claimed that people were born with natural oils that protected them from illness and that washing removed this natural protection. 400 years later Germ-theory vindicated the Jewish bible. But at the time, the haters were able to incite the masses against the Jews by conflating a truth –the Jews were less affected- with a lie –the Jews are poisoning the water supply.

Of course Oliver you recognize that American society, excluding your far-left and their Islamo-Facist allies (when Muslims are illicitly attacked, Jews are the first to defend them as they are for all minorities. Where is the Muslim voice?)is not so gullible. They will not start rioting against American-Jews, nor will they turn against Israel for irrational reasons. So you posit assertions based on the truth, while placing conspiratorial inventions next to those truths. You declare the Jews control the media, true, if you mean they are disproportionally represented. Then you add another truth, more Russians were killed then Jews in WWII, true. Then you go on to say Russia had it worse, but because the Jews control the media, Americans are made ignorant! Then you expand on the implications of Jewish control of the media: just as Americans are kept in the dark by Jews regarding the Russians so too are Americans hoodwinked by the Jewish controlled media which is why our “foreign policy is f###ed up for years”.

First off, don’t underestimate America's sense of history. Second, the Russians didn't lose 1/3 of their population. Third, why are Jews responsible for making sure people know about the suffering of our, then, enemies? Fourth, what makes you think that two truths -Jews are disproportionally represented in the media, and that more Russians perished during WW2- prove a lie “Jews have messed up American foreign policy by manipulating public and government opinion using their “control of the media”.

Oliver let us accept your toxic mixture of truths and lies: Jews' disproportionate representation equals "control" of Americas media. What has happened since the Jews controlled the media? Civil Rights, suppression of bigotry, the election of the most anti-Israel president since Carter, and unremitting criticism of the really evil man, no not Chavez or Ahmadinejad, but Bush!
On the other hand prior to Jewish “control of the media”, when people like you controlled the media: Jim Crow, slavery, unremitting biased criticism or outright lies, Vietnam etc. You want the media to support Stalin’s and Hitler’s legacy, or paint over Chavezs' suppression of freedoms, or Ahmadinjad's raping and murdering his way to election victory and supporting terrorism against our troops and our allies! Ah, then America will be free of Jewish control of the media!

The “Jewish” controlled media exposed a ring of Jewish organ traffickers, including Rabbis. But unlike what you would have liked, they didn't conclude from that that Jews are killing babies and stealing Palestinian organs. Instead the truth: organs that saved lives were being bought at really low prices and sold at exorbitant profits, while also avoiding the authorities. The “Jewish controlled media”, exposed Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo Bay, extraordinary rendition, domestic wire-tapping, the failures of Bush and less so Obama, supported Israel’s self-destruction with its expulsion of Israelis from Gaza, and with this article your subtly orchestrated bigotry.

The "Jewish media" refused to entertain unsubstantiated 9/11 conspiracy theories, just because there were serious abnormalities in the events leading up to 9/11. Your media, would have shifted a narrative based on readily apparent facts to a fictitious saga about the hidden hand of Jews and the CIA. As if Americans are so uneducated as not to recognize a classic anti-Semitic scapegoating when they see it. Yes, the “Jewish controlled Media” reported on government produced evidence leading up to the war in Iraq but Congress and America were firmly behind that war -not the Israeli lobby. Does this mean that Americas media is perfect, of course not, but that imperfection is not reflection of a Jewish conspiracy but human fallibility.


Then again, movie-director Stone, aren’t the Jews disproportionally represented in Hollywood, medicine, finance, law, politics, and Nobel prizes, does this mean that Jewish dominance reflects a white bearded blood sucking conspiracy OR is it akin to African-American dominance in sports.
The reason why Jews are disproportionally represented in Media, is because THEY ARE GOOD AT IT, not because of some conspiracy! Oliver I know you don't like it but in this country we put performance before race, ethnicity, AND religion!

Besides,Oliver, even if Jews do control America's media if you and your ilk had your chance, you would give us blood libels, communism, fascism, a loss of national pride, and irrational support for terrorism. Never (again) YOU ANTI-SEMITIC...!

Monday, July 12, 2010

Poetry With An Explanation: "Ever Been on a Blind Date on Steroids?"

Have you ever been on a blind date?

How about a shidduch date?

Which do you prefer?

The former, is set up by friends or,

has its genesis in a wink on one “date” site or the other.

They tell me,

as I have never experienced an ordinary blind date,

that you should have no expectations.

Mature means mother.

Pretty means nice.

Nice means…

After all can you trust,

a person to be honest about themselves

or a friend to be aware of their misguided motivations?

Is the latter any different than the former?

How so?

Perhaps it is the source.

A relative who has vetted the person for you

Done the research and decided

“I have a good feeling about this one.”

I am powerless, a man

used to the ways of nature

is now subjected to another’s subjective

Interpretation of the self, by the other.

Where do you meet a spouse or a long term intimate friend? Some go to the club and are satisfied for the moment. Others go to the library and are too timid to approach or are “ignored” for a book. Our friends, especially the ones who just got into a serious-relationship/married fell like they are now experts and found the perfect one for you. Don’t get me wrong most of my friends met their spouses through friends. My best friends met his wife at a party in my apartment. But for those not governed, or not wishing, to be governed by providence…

For the religious person there is an ostensibly unique approach. Here an individual, you, makes an active decision to allow someone else to actively search for your mate. A complete loss of pro-active power, no initiative required. Some in an effort to regain power reject, out of a state of confusion, or even immaturity. Others jump on every opportunity, after all my relative would never set me up with what they perceive to be what I want.

Don’t get me wrong I am not projecting resentment.

Just curious observations

It IS interesting.

So does the blind date differ from the shidduch date?

Is it not a matter of managing expectations?

If that’s the case the difference is not the type of date

but rather the reason why you agree to go on the date.

In the blind date your expectations are “blind”.

In the shidduch date your expectations are on steroids.

Justly so?

I don’t think so.

Semantics at play,

no difference,

just the label?

Ok.

So maybe we should just call it, I don’t know…

a blind date on steroids?

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Israel Firster??? That May Make YOU a Firster!

In recent months I have seen an uptick in the use of the term "Israel-firster". This term is at times used to besmirch consistently pro-Israel conservatives, but more often it is applied to any one who advocates strongly on behalf of Israel, especially if they happen to be Jewish. Unless the advocate is Israeli, the term implies, they are disloyal to America or whatever country the individual is from because they put Israel first.

To be fair, the abusers of this term are simply following their antecedents. The canard that Jews are disloyal to their country of citizenship is a as old as the bible. Pharaoh decreed that the Jews be enslaved because “they will side with our enemies”. Over 600 years later the viceroy to the Persian king Xerxes (though the exact king is disputed, Purim) passed a decree ordering the death of every single Jew in the Persian empire. Jews celebrate our victory over Pharaoh’s and Haman’s hate on Passover and Purim respectively. In pre-war Germany, despite heavy Jewish assimilation (including serving disproportionally in the Kaisers army, and the dominance of reform Judaism which was centered on giving up the central Jewish belief in the coming of the Messiah and the return to Israel), the claim that Jews were disloyal was prevalent. In that case the Jews were not as lucky.

So the users of the term Israel firsters have quite the pedigree.

But it is not enough to call them what they primarily are, anti-Semites, because they will respond “you always silence your critics by calling them anti-Semites”. Instead here is a logical argument that both refutes their claim and exposes them for what they, chiefly, are.

People that besmirch patriots of Jewish origin as Israeli firsters, shout “they push America into wars and cause American blood and treasure to be spilled for their good". Another claim they make is that it is obvious America should be like the rest of the world and condemn Israel so that we won’t be hated, but because of the “lobby” or because of Israeli firsters, America puts itself on the line for Israel.

The implication here is that any time America goes to war against an enemy that happens to also be an enemy of Israel, America is doing it to its own detriment. Or that when America gives loan guarantees or military hardware, to Israel, it causes a net loss for America. Or that America puts Turkey and Erdogan in its place, not because of their actions against Israel which strategically hurt America, but because Israel firsters are insidiously manipulating American politics.

Like the Turkish claims prevalent in Turkey, these canards are easily debunked.

America's war in Iraq may have been to the benefit of Israel, but it benefited Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Kuwait even more. Indeed the war eliminated Saddam, a man who invaded Kuawit and Iran and launched scuds into Saudi Arabia and Israel. Furthermore it made Iran, Israel’s biggest enemy, stronger because it eliminated Iran’s main secular rival/threat on its border. As for America fighting Israel’s wars with no Israeli blood being sacrificed: It is well known that America refused direct Israeli help during the first and the second Gulf wars so as not to openly antagonize the Arab street which backed America's intervention in Iraq (1). It is equally known that when Israeli population centers were attacked with Iraqi scuds during Gulf one, it did not respond so as not to jeopardize the American led coalition. Of course Israel’s intelligence in the middle-East is fully utilized by America and its real allies.

Also the firsters refuse to acknowledge that a significant majority of Americans, in every poll, consistently support Israel over its neighbors, to a tune of 60-40. They like to blame the media, as if there are not major media sources that are unrelenting in their biased criticism of Israel -New York Times and Huffington Post just to name two.

Finally what really unmasks those making Israel firster accusations is the fact that they never acknowledge that there are overriding political, strategic, and ideological reasons for America's support for Israel. Instead they say "look the whole world is against Israel", as if that’s a logical reason to stop supporting Israel. Obama reached out to the Muslim world. Those that were pro-America in the past continue to be so. Those that weren’t are no closer. It is not America's support for Israel that decides who supports or opposes America.

For those that dispute the above claims please take a moment from writing baseless comments on Huffington Post and educate yourself about the logical reasons for those that support Israel’s all-pervasive relationship with America. For example, http://pairspective.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=94:the-linkers-and-the-thinkers-is-americas-support-for-israel-hurting-america-part-3&catid=35:highlights&Itemid=92. Instead of hypothesizing that the reason they hate us is because we support Israel… ask yourself why do YOU hate Israel? Are you projecting your feelings on others?

Finally, Jews in America have every reason to support America's interests. After all it is this country that protects our freedoms. It is in this country where we are able to shine and succeed, and it is this country that supports our right to advocate on behalf of the land where our mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers live -to protect itself and succeed despite all the hate directed at it. Why do we love America? It is because this is a country that stands up for the truth, and goes against the irrational populist tides that are once again inundating the old world.

So why do some living in America and taking advantage of this great country attack America's choice -not criticize, not debate, but attack? Furthermore, why do most of these people, whom you derogatorily call flag wavers, or Israel firsters, support America's choice? Is it because they are in reality American firsters?!

To be fair just as all criticism of Israel and its supporters is not anti-Semitic so too are some who use the obnoxious term Israel firsters, not motivated by anti-Semitism. Rather they irrationally assume that every action that perpetuates a grievance they have towards American policy can’t be motivated by the desire, first and foremost, for this country to succeed. You think that it’s bad for this country. They think it is good. Fine, but don’t blindly conclude that they must be Israel firsters, because they can just as easily conclude that you put anti-Semitism, Hamas, Turkey, Islam, Iran, China, Congo, Sudan, Libya, North-Korea, and/or all the above terrorists before the good of our country. Which by the way makes YOU A FIRSTER!

Monday, June 28, 2010

In short, one more reason to vote Obama out of office.

Have you heard of Sholom Rubashkin? He is a philanthropist, father, husband, son, brother, and entrepreneur; The man who transformed a small kosher meat plant in Postville, Iowa into the biggest and most successful kosher meat operation in the world. That is until he was convicted on 86 counts of bank fraud and sentenced to 27 years of prison. Murderers, like Lemrick Nelson the man who stabbed Yankel Rosenbaum to death during a Black on Jewish riot- often receive single digit sentences. The fact that this is Rubashkin’s first conviction of any sort raises the question:

Why was a 51 year old man, basically given a life sentence, (if this ruling stands Rubashkin will be 77 when he is eligible for parole), for a first offense, when others convicted under similar circumstances were not?

Many in the Jewish community have offered the hackneyed, but substantial explanation, that anti-Semitism is at play. They offer historic evidence of America's legal record of dealing with high-profile Jewish criminals. For example the Rosenbergs, Jonathon Pollard , and Bernie Madoff. All of these infamous Jews were convicted criminals, and received severe sentences. Despite what Huffington Post and like-minded commentators will have you believe, Jack Abramoff was an exception not the rule, because of his connections in the white-house.

Others, mainly a few legal scholars, argue that the judge (who also happens to be the second harshest sentence producer in the nation)didn’t really have a choice.

Still there is another possible explanation.

It takes us back to 2006/2007 when two powerful organizations, PETA and the United Food and Commercial Workers Union, confronted Rubashkin.

PETA, the extremist animal-advocacy organization, has been targeting and besmirching kosher slaughter as inhuman for over a decade. This despite the fact that kosher slaughter is practiced as it is because it is considered the most humane manner of slaughter. Rubashkin's Agriprocessers, like most kosher slaughter houses practicing a millennia old tradition, refused to bow to PETA. Next, PETA turned to the far-left advocacy block to help them bring down Rubashkin.

The second organization, and by far the most significant, was the labor union which tried to shake Rubashkin down and at the same time force his employees to join their union.

This is key to understanding the Rubashkin case. After all who are the two biggest groups supporting Obama? Our president, a community activist, was put in power not so much by Jews as he was by the still-powerful unions. Who supported Obama in his bid for the presidency? The Unions and the far-left (not that the far-left is homogeneous, but PETA draws strongly from far-left ideology) of course.

This argument is bolstered by recent history -Obama has not shied away from putting his weight behind the unions before.

After a series of over-publicized Toyota brake mishaps, the administration's transportation secretary Ray Lahood, testified in front of congress on February 3rd of this year that “if anybody owns one of these vehicles [Toyota], stop driving it.” Anyone in the industry can tell you that all companies experience problems of the same magnitude.

The Obama administration had no problem interfering with our “free” enterprise and gave a tremendous edge to Toyota’s major competitor in America -owned by America- GM.

It should come as no surprise that the Rubashkin conviction was a result not only of a law and order judge gone-wild (with tenure), and residual anti-Semitism, but more so as a consequence of the unions/Obama partnership.

No I'm not saying this is Obama's fault, only that Rubashkins sentence would have been a lot less likely under a president that wasn't in bed with the Unions.

In short, one more reason to vote Obama out of office.