This New York Post article
http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/manhattan/hero_unwelcome_Zi3u1fwtRpo87vXAiAQfSN
leads me to ask:
Is it any surprise that a University that embraces “apartheid week” and hosts the likes of Ahmadinejad would also be a place where wounded veterans are jeered for sharing their opinion? Why should a man who served his country be called a racist for voicing his opinion at a forum expressly established to discuss whether the army should be allowed to recruit on Columbia’s campus? Did the veteran make the choice to accept faulty intelligence from a disaffected Iraqi –is it his fault we went to war? Does he spend his every waking hour recruiting, mostly, ignorant students to malign, libel, and demonize Israel and the American-right? Is he on record calling for the genocide of an entire nation?!
Following America’s shameful treatment of Vietnam War veterans (who also fought in a war that was imposed on them) our society was supposed to have repented. America’s abysmal treatment of its veterans prompted our government to pass an array of popular legislation aimed at ensuring that our soldiers and veterans would receive the respect and dignified assistance they deserved. Why than do ostensibly educated students –the cream of the crop- find it tolerable, if not commendable, to label our hero’s “racist”. Why do like-minded students, like the ones in this story, find it acceptable to prevent Ann Coulter, Michael Oran, and veterans from sharing their opinions, but are the first to support the proliferation of Ahmadinejad’s’ genocidal rants. Is this liberalism? How did the liberal cause become one half of the unholy alliance between "absolute freedom" Liberals and sharia-imposing Muslim extremists?
Columbia University may be an Ivy League school and an institution that I considered applying to, but it is also a collective voice for disoriented ethics and irrational activism.
Showing posts with label free speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free speech. Show all posts
Monday, February 21, 2011
Sunday, August 8, 2010
Not After 9/11, NOW! Why are Anti-Mosque Protests Sweeping Across America ?
I remember walking through Manhattans Mid-town weeks after 9/11 and I was both dismayed and proud of what I encountered. The protesters were advocating against going to war.
What we didn't see was wide-spread attacks on Muslims. On the contrary most political and religious leaders defended Islam and their American followers. Americans are proud of that too.
Almost 10 years later a new Mosque/community center has been proposed and approved by NYC only blocks away from a ground zero monument yet to be completed. To the families of victims it is seen as the ultimate insult, however legal, to the memory of their loved ones and many regular-Americans agree.
Then we saw The New York Times (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/08/us/08mosque.html?_r=1) published an article exposing the growing trend of anti-Mosque protests highlighting the blatant arguments to suppress religious freedom. The NYT articles point was intended not only to expose a troubling trend but also to conflate the non-racist arguments against the ground zero mosque with the racist protests elsewhere; with the intent of discrediting the arguments against the ground zero mosque.
Yet the fact remains, after 9/11 there was little anti-Islam activity, whereas, now Mosque building across Amercia –reflecting a constitutional right to practice religious freedom- is being challenged!
Recently I have been called a bigot by a reader of my blog who opposed my article questioning the reasoning of building a Mosque so close to ground zero. The full essay can be viewed at http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/05/between-mosque-and-hard-place.html. But the thesis is that Muslims know there are questions about their beliefs and anger against the actions committed by people who claim to be Muslims. So I asked why not avoid insulting people? What was gained by using religious freedom to again victimize the victims? Did they expect such an actions to strengthen the harmony between Americas religious communities? My conclusion was that whatever the intentions, they forced the average American to choose between a Mosque -representing religious freedom- and a hard place -representing the insult and disregard that victims of 9/11 feel.
Indeed after 9/11 there was no “choice”, every community, except for a few who exercised their freedom to dance in New Jersey as the towers and people burned, gathered together and denounced the suicide-murder. For most Americans, like myself, it was another instance of the triumph of American exceptionalism -rationality and law trumped irrational anger and frustration, and there were no wide-spread attacks on Muslim-American community. After all Muslim were also lost in the inferno of hate, many spoke out against the terror, their religion was victimized by their suicidal coreligionists.
Yet now Americans turn on their tv’s and they see Muslims completely rejecting the feelings of many good and honest Americans. The same America that elected a Black president and refused to blame Islam for Fort Hood the attempted Christmas-day bombing, despite 9/11… Muslim-Americans like Farreed Zakaree, the CNN anchor and writer who returned an ADL award, because the ADL DID recognize the legitimacy, however irrational, of the victims feelings and opposed the mosque ON THOSE GROUNDS.
Muslim-Americans the overwhelming majority who espouse peace could have come out and declared
“WE ARE A PEACFUL RELIGOUN WE BELIEVED THIS MOSQUE WOULD FOSTER UNDERSTANDING AND HARMONY, BUT FOR THE SAKE OF PEACE AND THE STILL TRAUMATIZED VICTIMS, ESSPECIALY CONSIDERING RECENT AMERICAN HISTORY, WE WILL FIND A LESS SENSATIVE AREA IN LOWER MANHATTAN FOR THIS MOSQUE.”
Instead Muslims told me that they opposed the Mosque because of the unnecessary disunity it causes, but now support it because they feel under attack. But I say this is not the way you respond to an attack in America. Not one major America-Muslim organization publicized and acknowledged the feelings of the victims. Not one organization said “you know what we understand”!
Indeed America refuses to blame American-Muslims for the horror committed in its name, and I believe it will continue to do so.
When Americans saw American-Muslims going out of their way to insult America. They said “perhaps Muslims don’t understand the pain this mosque is causing”, let us explain it to them -dissuade them from using this location. That didn’t work. So then they asked “is this what we can expect from the Muslim-American community in the future”? To deliberately insult, like the fringe racists who now feel free to openly stand in front of Mosques with dogs at their side hurling insults? To use freedom of religion to create disharmony amongst religious communities? To be unable to adjust to real concerns by deeply hurt people? To add insult to injury and label the emotionally injured who ONLY remember their children and parents and call them bigots!!! Is this a religion of understanding is this a community which has leaders that understand that the law is a means for coexistence not an ends on to itself?
Of course protesting in front of mosques simply because they are Muslim institutions is wrong. Of course the Mosque/community center is legal, and Muslims are free to build anywhere the law allows them! Of course American-Muslims, (except the American-Muslims that provided support to the 9/11 hijackers) are not to blame for 9/11 and to blame them is wrong! Of Course!
But do Muslim-Americans understand that this Mosque will achieve the what the hijackers were unable to achieve, wide-spread religious conflict? Do Muslim-Americans not feel the grief that so many Americans victimized by 9/11 feel?
Then again by now the Mosque supporters realize what they are doing and continue to act, if they didn't at the onset.
If that is the case it does not make Mosque protesting outside of the ground zero mosque right, but it certainly explains it.
What we didn't see was wide-spread attacks on Muslims. On the contrary most political and religious leaders defended Islam and their American followers. Americans are proud of that too.
Almost 10 years later a new Mosque/community center has been proposed and approved by NYC only blocks away from a ground zero monument yet to be completed. To the families of victims it is seen as the ultimate insult, however legal, to the memory of their loved ones and many regular-Americans agree.
Then we saw The New York Times (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/08/us/08mosque.html?_r=1) published an article exposing the growing trend of anti-Mosque protests highlighting the blatant arguments to suppress religious freedom. The NYT articles point was intended not only to expose a troubling trend but also to conflate the non-racist arguments against the ground zero mosque with the racist protests elsewhere; with the intent of discrediting the arguments against the ground zero mosque.
Yet the fact remains, after 9/11 there was little anti-Islam activity, whereas, now Mosque building across Amercia –reflecting a constitutional right to practice religious freedom- is being challenged!
Recently I have been called a bigot by a reader of my blog who opposed my article questioning the reasoning of building a Mosque so close to ground zero. The full essay can be viewed at http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/05/between-mosque-and-hard-place.html. But the thesis is that Muslims know there are questions about their beliefs and anger against the actions committed by people who claim to be Muslims. So I asked why not avoid insulting people? What was gained by using religious freedom to again victimize the victims? Did they expect such an actions to strengthen the harmony between Americas religious communities? My conclusion was that whatever the intentions, they forced the average American to choose between a Mosque -representing religious freedom- and a hard place -representing the insult and disregard that victims of 9/11 feel.
Indeed after 9/11 there was no “choice”, every community, except for a few who exercised their freedom to dance in New Jersey as the towers and people burned, gathered together and denounced the suicide-murder. For most Americans, like myself, it was another instance of the triumph of American exceptionalism -rationality and law trumped irrational anger and frustration, and there were no wide-spread attacks on Muslim-American community. After all Muslim were also lost in the inferno of hate, many spoke out against the terror, their religion was victimized by their suicidal coreligionists.
Yet now Americans turn on their tv’s and they see Muslims completely rejecting the feelings of many good and honest Americans. The same America that elected a Black president and refused to blame Islam for Fort Hood the attempted Christmas-day bombing, despite 9/11… Muslim-Americans like Farreed Zakaree, the CNN anchor and writer who returned an ADL award, because the ADL DID recognize the legitimacy, however irrational, of the victims feelings and opposed the mosque ON THOSE GROUNDS.
Muslim-Americans the overwhelming majority who espouse peace could have come out and declared
“WE ARE A PEACFUL RELIGOUN WE BELIEVED THIS MOSQUE WOULD FOSTER UNDERSTANDING AND HARMONY, BUT FOR THE SAKE OF PEACE AND THE STILL TRAUMATIZED VICTIMS, ESSPECIALY CONSIDERING RECENT AMERICAN HISTORY, WE WILL FIND A LESS SENSATIVE AREA IN LOWER MANHATTAN FOR THIS MOSQUE.”
Instead Muslims told me that they opposed the Mosque because of the unnecessary disunity it causes, but now support it because they feel under attack. But I say this is not the way you respond to an attack in America. Not one major America-Muslim organization publicized and acknowledged the feelings of the victims. Not one organization said “you know what we understand”!
Indeed America refuses to blame American-Muslims for the horror committed in its name, and I believe it will continue to do so.
When Americans saw American-Muslims going out of their way to insult America. They said “perhaps Muslims don’t understand the pain this mosque is causing”, let us explain it to them -dissuade them from using this location. That didn’t work. So then they asked “is this what we can expect from the Muslim-American community in the future”? To deliberately insult, like the fringe racists who now feel free to openly stand in front of Mosques with dogs at their side hurling insults? To use freedom of religion to create disharmony amongst religious communities? To be unable to adjust to real concerns by deeply hurt people? To add insult to injury and label the emotionally injured who ONLY remember their children and parents and call them bigots!!! Is this a religion of understanding is this a community which has leaders that understand that the law is a means for coexistence not an ends on to itself?
Of course protesting in front of mosques simply because they are Muslim institutions is wrong. Of course the Mosque/community center is legal, and Muslims are free to build anywhere the law allows them! Of course American-Muslims, (except the American-Muslims that provided support to the 9/11 hijackers) are not to blame for 9/11 and to blame them is wrong! Of Course!
But do Muslim-Americans understand that this Mosque will achieve the what the hijackers were unable to achieve, wide-spread religious conflict? Do Muslim-Americans not feel the grief that so many Americans victimized by 9/11 feel?
Then again by now the Mosque supporters realize what they are doing and continue to act, if they didn't at the onset.
If that is the case it does not make Mosque protesting outside of the ground zero mosque right, but it certainly explains it.
Labels:
9/11,
America,
free speech,
freedom of religion,
ground zero,
Islam,
mosque,
New York Times
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Victims mentality on a societal level?
The only thing Western Society savors more than its right to free speech, is defending that right. The recent melee between Comedy Central’s South Park censorship of a show depicting Muhammad and the American public is a perfect example. The Muslim group, revolution, “informed” South Park and co. that Theo Van Gogh was on their minds. Comedy Central capitulated and the American free speech obsession -no pun intended- was set in motion.
I wonder whether we have been completely fair in our criticisms. Free speech has evolved over the last century and has been extended to protect everything from explicit novelettes to good old Hugh Hefner exuberance. However, before you go streaking through your neighborhood, claiming artistic expression, know this. Our supreme court, has ruled that
The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent. falsely shouting fire in t a theater (Schenck v. United States,1919).
Thus our free speech loving society has already drawn the line, when life is threatened speech is no longer free.
As far as I’m concerned the only difference between Comedy Central and Co., which many now abhor, and the Supreme Court, in all its subjective glory, is that Comedy Central didn’t wait until the government confirmed that there was a clear and present danger. Put otherwise. The real tragedy here is that we have targeted the victim, for their spinelessness while suppressing the perpetrators brazenness.
Victim mentality on a societal level?
I wonder whether we have been completely fair in our criticisms. Free speech has evolved over the last century and has been extended to protect everything from explicit novelettes to good old Hugh Hefner exuberance. However, before you go streaking through your neighborhood, claiming artistic expression, know this. Our supreme court, has ruled that
The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent. falsely shouting fire in t a theater (Schenck v. United States,1919).
Thus our free speech loving society has already drawn the line, when life is threatened speech is no longer free.
As far as I’m concerned the only difference between Comedy Central and Co., which many now abhor, and the Supreme Court, in all its subjective glory, is that Comedy Central didn’t wait until the government confirmed that there was a clear and present danger. Put otherwise. The real tragedy here is that we have targeted the victim, for their spinelessness while suppressing the perpetrators brazenness.
Victim mentality on a societal level?
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Ann Coulter silenced Mahmoud Ahmadinejad encouraged: Why?
It is 2008 world leaders and despots alike are meeting in New York City for the annual UNGA summit of world leaders. Columbia University invites Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to speak to the student body to present his "world view".
Outside various Jewish, Israeli, and moral minded individuals gathered to protest Columbia's decision to lend its prestigious name to the man who proclaimed "Israel should be wiped off the map" and an unabashed supporter of terrorist organizations spanning the globe.
The protests were loud and angry. For good reason. But Ahmadinejad ascended to the podium of liberalism and held forth on how there are no homosexuals in Iran!
Tuesday March 23, 2010 controversial conservative commentator Ann Coulter was scheduled to speak at the University of Ottawa Canada. But her speech was canceled due to the angry -frothing at the mouth- crowd who swore to physically prevent Coulter's speech. The police refused to uphold their mandate to protect free speech. The University of Ottawa vice-president and provost Francois Houleo warned her "that freedom of speech is defined differently in Canada than in the U.S. and that she should take care not to step over the line" (The Vancouver Sun). A veiled threat if there ever was one.
When pro-Israel students where accosted by a group of anti-Israel students at York University, also in Canada, during a debate that had sprung up between the Hasbara (explanation) people and the anti-Israel individuals. It quickly escalated into an angry mob of around 50 students, who surrounded the group and chanted anti-Israel and anti-Semitic slurs.
This has been going on for some time and seldom gets reported or discussed. All over the world the majority of "whatever" (the religious, political etc. majority) is imposing itself, often resorting to defending irrational views with violence.
Indeed America and Israel are the last two countries in this world where EVERY view expressed PEACEFULLY is allowed. But there has been a sea change here in the states.
In Columbia and many other universities across America "apartheid week" which basically is a week of Israel bashing, was in full swing, but when Israeli Ambassador to the United State Michael Oren attempted to speak at the University of California Irvin he was interrupted repeatedly, and like Coulter almost silenced!
We in the states must be ever more vigilant. True the old enemy was oppressive governments (Soviet Union, China, Saudi Arabia, Iran etc.) suppressing speech. But don't be fooled it is just as dangerous and undemocratic for majority factions to suppress speech.
Some of my friends have recently asked me why it seems that the most vocal opponents of Islam in America are Jews and conservatives.
I respond with my own observation of a global trend
...anyone who is remotely perceived as pro-Israel OR anti-Muslim is prevented from voicing their opinion. If however, the individual in question is perceived as anti-Israel OR pro-Muslim they are encouraged.
Is it any surprise then that those in America who have for 300 plus years experienced freedom from violence and oppression of the majority OR minority point out a group that has been attacking them all over the world Mumbai, London, Sydney, Queens, Israel, Russia, etc.(do a Google search blank attacks Jews in blank)?
YES JEWS AND OTHERS ARE AFRAID THAT THIS WILL HAPPEN HERE AND THEIR FEARS ARE JUSTIFIED AS THIS TYRANNY OF THOUGHT AND ACTION SWIMS ACROSS THE OCEAN INTO CANADA, CALIFORNIA...
WHY?
Outside various Jewish, Israeli, and moral minded individuals gathered to protest Columbia's decision to lend its prestigious name to the man who proclaimed "Israel should be wiped off the map" and an unabashed supporter of terrorist organizations spanning the globe.
The protests were loud and angry. For good reason. But Ahmadinejad ascended to the podium of liberalism and held forth on how there are no homosexuals in Iran!
Tuesday March 23, 2010 controversial conservative commentator Ann Coulter was scheduled to speak at the University of Ottawa Canada. But her speech was canceled due to the angry -frothing at the mouth- crowd who swore to physically prevent Coulter's speech. The police refused to uphold their mandate to protect free speech. The University of Ottawa vice-president and provost Francois Houleo warned her "that freedom of speech is defined differently in Canada than in the U.S. and that she should take care not to step over the line" (The Vancouver Sun). A veiled threat if there ever was one.
When pro-Israel students where accosted by a group of anti-Israel students at York University, also in Canada, during a debate that had sprung up between the Hasbara (explanation) people and the anti-Israel individuals. It quickly escalated into an angry mob of around 50 students, who surrounded the group and chanted anti-Israel and anti-Semitic slurs.
This has been going on for some time and seldom gets reported or discussed. All over the world the majority of "whatever" (the religious, political etc. majority) is imposing itself, often resorting to defending irrational views with violence.
Indeed America and Israel are the last two countries in this world where EVERY view expressed PEACEFULLY is allowed. But there has been a sea change here in the states.
In Columbia and many other universities across America "apartheid week" which basically is a week of Israel bashing, was in full swing, but when Israeli Ambassador to the United State Michael Oren attempted to speak at the University of California Irvin he was interrupted repeatedly, and like Coulter almost silenced!
We in the states must be ever more vigilant. True the old enemy was oppressive governments (Soviet Union, China, Saudi Arabia, Iran etc.) suppressing speech. But don't be fooled it is just as dangerous and undemocratic for majority factions to suppress speech.
Some of my friends have recently asked me why it seems that the most vocal opponents of Islam in America are Jews and conservatives.
I respond with my own observation of a global trend
...anyone who is remotely perceived as pro-Israel OR anti-Muslim is prevented from voicing their opinion. If however, the individual in question is perceived as anti-Israel OR pro-Muslim they are encouraged.
Is it any surprise then that those in America who have for 300 plus years experienced freedom from violence and oppression of the majority OR minority point out a group that has been attacking them all over the world Mumbai, London, Sydney, Queens, Israel, Russia, etc.(do a Google search blank attacks Jews in blank)?
YES JEWS AND OTHERS ARE AFRAID THAT THIS WILL HAPPEN HERE AND THEIR FEARS ARE JUSTIFIED AS THIS TYRANNY OF THOUGHT AND ACTION SWIMS ACROSS THE OCEAN INTO CANADA, CALIFORNIA...
WHY?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)