The PLO Representative to the United States, Maen Rashid Areikat, spoke today at the Middle East Institute of Columbia University. Mr. Areikat was asked by my friend whether he believed that the current US sponsored Peace effort, towards a two state solution was more plausible then a one state solution?
Mr. Areikat responded with standard diplomatic circumlocution, that Israel has three choices.
1. Become an apartheid state, by both refusing to negotiate for a Palestinian State and preventing West Bank Palestinians from achieving full Israeli citizenship.
2. Accept a two state solution.
3. A one state solution, by giving West Bank residents full Israeli citizenship.
But I disagree Israel has only one choice:
From Areikat’s perspective, the creation of Israel alienated an entire population, and he is right.
Perhaps this population caused its own downfall and continues to miss opportunities, -failed leadership and corruption etc.- but as any cognitive psychologist will tell you it is perception not reality that is important.
It is equally true that regardless of the justness of Israel’s position the Palestinians are not going away.
But Mr. Areikat, like so many others, misses the underlying point. Israel is not just another nation where citizens define their allegiance by rooting for their national-sports team. Israel is not just a state where Jews are a majority. It is a place defined by its Jewish majority.
To repeat:
For 2000 years the worlds Jews, and their resourcefulness, were at the whim of tyrants, imams, and popes. True in the Ottoman Empire, Muslim ruled Iberia (Spain),15th century Poland, and 19th century Germany Jews were allowed to live in peace, but they were never equal citizens. And as we know now their safety was as transient, as the laws that protected them. It is also true that America, my country, has been unwavering in its protection of its Jewish minority, but even here Jews are constantly reminded by the likes of Helen Thomase, Mel Gibson, and Oliver Stone -to name a few- that America the beautiful can be high-jacked by ugly Americans.
Now Jews finally have a state, not a decaying dessert kingdom, but a developed, and pluralistic nation in the very same geography of our ancient homeland. A place where I, an American, can choose to move and thrive and where my fellow Jews who are being firebombed and beaten (usually by disaffected un-integrated [Chancellor Angela Merkel anyone] Muslim immigrant-youth)are now running.
So why should Israel's support a two state solution only to be hedged in by a proven enemy from every side?
1967 borders?!
You mean to say Israel should allow itself to be effectively split in half? Because 1967 borders=20; 20 miles wide at its most narrow point, which is also smack in the middle of Israel. Dismantling settlements?!
You mean to say that Israel should force 325,000 Jews from their homes? Isn't that exactly what Palestinians claim happened to them?
Worse why should Israel support a one state solution only to lose its Jewish majority and place itself in the hands -once again- of a people who, justly or otherwise, have been taught to hate and have murdered out of hate?
Indeed even if they were peace loving Europeans (ahem hem) why take the chance?
I know, the moral arguments coming from the left and Muslims are compelling.
But from my perspective this is not about who is the bigger victim of circumstance or whether Israel deserves all the world’s condemnation, it's not even about the moral issues of "occupation".
It's about Israel's mission to preclude another 2000 years of forced subjection to unfettered human hate. Jews are no longer defenseless. For this reason Israel has only one choice, a Jewish Majority at all costs!
Showing posts with label helen thomas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label helen thomas. Show all posts
Monday, October 18, 2010
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
Why Helen Thomas Resigned:
Helen Thomas was the longest serving journalist in the White House Press Corp. At the ripe old age of 89 she resigned from her post, after she candidly was recorded as saying that the Jews should get the hell out Israel, and go back to Poland and Germany.
While Thomas, the daughter of Lebanese immigrants was never, or ever tried to be, seen as pro-Israel, she was always given the benefit of the doubt that her views were political by nature. That is, she opposed Israel not because it is a Jewish state, but because of the usual political arguments.
Yes the Jewish and Israeli community both here and abroad is very sensitive to criticism, but there is still a small majority which believes that criticism of Israel is not synonymous with anti-Semitism. I dealt with this very issue in a previous post “http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/04/i-have-no-problem-with-jews-its-just.html which I hope you will read.
This despite the disappointing and confused responses by some in the Jewish community, posting on Huffington post (which relished the opportunity to publish that article) and other less significant media outlets. Please, when you are dealing with such an important issue, you have to argue coherently and effectively. Stick to the issue!
With that necessary digression aside, I accept the majority position, with the caveat that just because anti-Semitism is not inherent to criticism of Israel does not automatically mean that anti-Semitism is not often behind that criticism. Indeed many astute followers of the news have become adept at distinguishing the two.
Thomas was one of these respected journalists, and was beleived to reflect the above nuanced position -criticism without anti-Semitism.
Until.
Until she made her comments.
But even now let us not jump to conclusions.
What did she say?
Did she make a distinction between Israeli's and Jews? Did she make a distinction between Israeli's from Europe and Israeli's that lived in Israel and surrounding Arab nations in an unbroken chain for over 3,000 years? No and no. After all it was only some Jews who came from the death camps of Germany and Poland. But she said “they” should get the hell out of Palestine.
Did she differentiate between pre and post 1967 borders? Did she mean that only the West Bank and Gaza is Palestine? No, and no. If she meant to, then she should have said “let them go back to Israel proper”.
What I infer from her comments is that she
1. She denies the existence/legitimacy of the State of Israel, akin to HAMAS’s extremist position.
2. She does not distinguish between Israelis and Jews, which means that decades of her extreme criticism of Israel were inherently directed at Jews.
Does the above mean that Thomas is an anti-Semite? Certainly not the conventional type that Jews are all too familiar with, you know the Neo-Nazi or frothing at the mouth protester at an ant-Israel rally. If she is an anti-Semite, she is more like the sophisticated Mel Gibson type. You know, making movies that indirectly affirm anti-Semitic notions, or effectively hiding beliefs until that one candid moment when it all comes out.
However her resignation was justified. Not because of the insidious Israeli lobby, our oversensitive culture, or even her almost blatant anti-Semitism, but because
3. she completely lacks, or perhaps recently lost, the sensitivity that is integral to the fair, honest, and democratic exchange of ideas that the majority of Americans cherish.
and
4. she is not capable of objective reporting on Israel, and who knows what else. This is not to say that she has no right to her personal opinion, however egregious and extreme, but rather that her views compromise her ability to report to us in an as unbiased manner as possible (please see inside.ptribune.com for more on this point)
Finally, her resignation proves, that America, despite all its imperfection, is still a great and blessed country. At the end of the day that's why Helen Thomas resigned.
While Thomas, the daughter of Lebanese immigrants was never, or ever tried to be, seen as pro-Israel, she was always given the benefit of the doubt that her views were political by nature. That is, she opposed Israel not because it is a Jewish state, but because of the usual political arguments.
Yes the Jewish and Israeli community both here and abroad is very sensitive to criticism, but there is still a small majority which believes that criticism of Israel is not synonymous with anti-Semitism. I dealt with this very issue in a previous post “http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/04/i-have-no-problem-with-jews-its-just.html which I hope you will read.
This despite the disappointing and confused responses by some in the Jewish community, posting on Huffington post (which relished the opportunity to publish that article) and other less significant media outlets. Please, when you are dealing with such an important issue, you have to argue coherently and effectively. Stick to the issue!
With that necessary digression aside, I accept the majority position, with the caveat that just because anti-Semitism is not inherent to criticism of Israel does not automatically mean that anti-Semitism is not often behind that criticism. Indeed many astute followers of the news have become adept at distinguishing the two.
Thomas was one of these respected journalists, and was beleived to reflect the above nuanced position -criticism without anti-Semitism.
Until.
Until she made her comments.
But even now let us not jump to conclusions.
What did she say?
Did she make a distinction between Israeli's and Jews? Did she make a distinction between Israeli's from Europe and Israeli's that lived in Israel and surrounding Arab nations in an unbroken chain for over 3,000 years? No and no. After all it was only some Jews who came from the death camps of Germany and Poland. But she said “they” should get the hell out of Palestine.
Did she differentiate between pre and post 1967 borders? Did she mean that only the West Bank and Gaza is Palestine? No, and no. If she meant to, then she should have said “let them go back to Israel proper”.
What I infer from her comments is that she
1. She denies the existence/legitimacy of the State of Israel, akin to HAMAS’s extremist position.
2. She does not distinguish between Israelis and Jews, which means that decades of her extreme criticism of Israel were inherently directed at Jews.
Does the above mean that Thomas is an anti-Semite? Certainly not the conventional type that Jews are all too familiar with, you know the Neo-Nazi or frothing at the mouth protester at an ant-Israel rally. If she is an anti-Semite, she is more like the sophisticated Mel Gibson type. You know, making movies that indirectly affirm anti-Semitic notions, or effectively hiding beliefs until that one candid moment when it all comes out.
However her resignation was justified. Not because of the insidious Israeli lobby, our oversensitive culture, or even her almost blatant anti-Semitism, but because
3. she completely lacks, or perhaps recently lost, the sensitivity that is integral to the fair, honest, and democratic exchange of ideas that the majority of Americans cherish.
and
4. she is not capable of objective reporting on Israel, and who knows what else. This is not to say that she has no right to her personal opinion, however egregious and extreme, but rather that her views compromise her ability to report to us in an as unbiased manner as possible (please see inside.ptribune.com for more on this point)
Finally, her resignation proves, that America, despite all its imperfection, is still a great and blessed country. At the end of the day that's why Helen Thomas resigned.
Labels:
America,
anti-Semitism,
helen thomas,
jews,
objective journalism
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)