Showing posts with label Erdogan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Erdogan. Show all posts

Friday, July 23, 2010

Why Did Netanyahu Agree To Return The Confiscated Flotilla Ships?!

On July 23, in conference with his "council of seven", Netanyahu announced that Israel will accede to Turkey’s demand that Israel return the confiscated flotilla ships. Debka.com reports that Netanyahu once again has misguided hopes that the Israeli-Turkish relationship can be revived. “Misguided” because this is only the latest effort to engage with Turkey, all the previous initiatives failed. It was only last month that a failed “secret” meeting between trade and labor minister Ben-Eliezer and Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu blew up in Netanyahu’s face because Lieberman, Israel’s foreign minister, was not consulted with.

One can only wonder why Netanyahu agreed to return the ships. Some see it as a botched effort to head off yet another biased UN probe, this time investigating the flotilla fiasco. Others see it as a way to support the opposition's stance in Turkey, especially the military because it will show that Israel does want a positive relationship. The opposition and military in Turkey understands this and will use Israel’s action as proof of the potential for a return to normal relations (please see post http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/05/erdogan-and-turkey-are-israels-right.html). This assertion is supported by the fact that Israel actually transferred the final four Heron UAV’s to Turkey, i.e. Israel is maintaining its military ties. At the same time Turkey turned around and violated the terms of sale when they used the UAV’s to target PKK fighters in Syria. By using Israeli UAV’s in conjunction with Syria, Turkey is sharing Israeli military secrets with a nation that it is in a state of war with Israel.

Regardless, Netanyahu looks like an unrepentant fool.

It is clear that Erdogan’s Turkey will continue on its path of reckless hostility towards Israel, even while the government's domestic position continues to weaken. Furthermore there is conclusive evidence, coming from Ankara, that Ankara had good reason to support IHH’s botched efforts (NYT, http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/16/world/middleeast/16turkey.html). Ankara enabled a pivotal event in an ongoing proxy war on Israel the moment the boat full of “activists” embarked with the approval of Ankara with aims of defying Jerusalem. To those that argue that it was not the government of Turkey which aided and abetted the enemies of Israel, the flotilla, but rather a private charity organization, consider this: Turkey openly meets with Hamas leaders, the sworn enemies of Israel (which I will address in the near future), offering legitimacy, encouragement, and who knows what else. Turkey openly and unabashedly supports a terrorist organization whose goal is the destruction of Israel. So why wouldn’t Erdogan’s government covertly support the homicidal flotilla? Erdogan’s Turkey perceives Israel as a barrier to its designs on becoming the regional power.

You would think that the ultimate victor in the flotilla encounter (if that term can be used), Israel, would not return the vehicles of war to its enemy.

Either Netanyahu doesn’t understand that Erdogan’s Turkey is an enemy, or there is something else amiss.

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

No Mention of Turkey in the Obama/Netanyahu Press-Conference

This afternoon Barack H. Obama and Benjamin Netanyahu held a post meeting press-conference. They discussed Iran, the peace process, Gaza, Israeli nuclear arms, and even answered a question on the settlement freeze by an intrepid Israeli journalist. But no mention of Turkey’s demand for a UN “impartial inquiry” into the Flotilla provocation with a bad ending or a request that Israel apologize to Turkey. In fact while the Arab states, Hamas, Iran, and even Netanyahu’s Israel speech congratulating America on July fourth, were mentioned Turkey was not (http://www.c-span.org/Watch/Media/2010/07/06/HP/R/35121/President+Obama+USIsrael+bond+unbreakable.aspx).

Of course Turkey may have been discussed behind closed doors. After all the Turkey-Israel alliance in the Middle-East is in everyone’s interest. However as far as the public eye can see Turkey was simply ignored. This despite the fact that the meeting was supposed to occur on March 31, but was postponed by the flotilla incident. Furthermore Erdogan’s Turkey has put tremendous political capital into publicly demonizing Israel, whether at the UNGA, UNSC, or at the recent Baltic summit. It comes as a surprise that Turkey didn’t even warrant a passing mention, even by the journalists during the Q&A.

Why?

First of all as the mid-term elections approach, Obama is attempting to affirm his relationship with Israel and pander to the over 65% of Americans who strongly support a robust American-Israel alliance. Netanyahu, for his part, needs Obama’s support on a number of strategic issues as well as his approval, so that this time when he comes back to Israel the media won't go into a frenzy about how Israel lost America's support. It may also be a non-verbal Que to Turkey to play nice or not play at all.

But the why is not as significant as the results.

If you have a chance please watch and listen as Netanyahu begins his part of the press-conference (minute 7:30). He mentions that not everything is said openly and then he immediately continues to discuss a “new” danger in the Middle-East with a final segue into reiterating the moral reasons to oppose Iran –its brutal oppression of its own people. One could easily conclude that Netanyahu was referring to a segment of a conversation not mentioned –Turkey. How Turkey's policy was a new threat, and that its stated reasons for supporting Israel’s enemies, “occupation siege…”, were hypocritical considering they are supporting a repressive Iranian regime.

Then Netanyahu concluded that Obama affirmed the USA-Israel relationship behind closed doors and in public. Clearly Turkey has not accomplished much. Erdogan’s rhetoric or political shenanigans has not separated America from Israel, on the contrary.

Sunday, June 13, 2010

Saudi Arabia and Israel! Really?

The Timesoline ://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/middle_east/article7148555.ece reported Saturday that Saudi Arabia has established a narrow corridor for Israel, or America, for use to attack Iranian nuclear facilities. Intelligence sources (http://www.debka.com/article/8845/) are reporting that the Saudis have run drills preparing to stand down their comprehensive air defenses for just such an eventuality. Predictably, the Saudis denied the "accusation".

Though Israel and America continue their petty quibbling over the flotilla debacle -spurred on by an inept Obama administration- and are unlikely to take advantage, I would like to attempt to evaluate the Saudis offer, from the Israeli perspective.

First, Israel should never forget that it was the Saudis, not the Iranians, who first helped establish the framework and infrastructure for international Islamic terror that plagues Israel. Moreover, the Saudis, though improved, have an abysmal human rights record. For that reason alone Israel should be weary.

Two, the Saudis, and most Arab nations, refuse to recognize the state of Israel, but now realize that it is precisely the non-existent Israel that stands between them, the Sunni Arabs nations (excluding Lebanon, and to a lesser degree Syria), and the tyrannical Shiite Mullahs of Iran.

Three, the Saudis as well as the other Arab nations were shocked by the speedy emergence of the non-Arab alliance that sandwiches them between Iran and Turkey (http://www.debka.com/article/8845/). Past Ottoman oppression and Iranian aspirations may be overlooked by the deprived Israel-hating Arab street, but the elites of the Arab nations know who their enemy really is.

So what should Israel do?

First, should Israel make the necessary decision to attack Iran, there will be serious repercussions for Israel. On the diplomatic front, there is no shortage of anti-Israel sentiment. Even in America, there are those on the far-left who savor the opportunity to bolster their highly questionable claim that Israel is a strategic liability America (please see post series "the thinkers and the linkers", for more on this). Ironically, the very Arab nations that Israel will save will likely be the first to condemn Israel.

On the military front, while it is not clear that an Israeli attack will be completely successful, it is clear that Iran will let loose its proxy terror apparatus, Hezbollah and Hamas. These organizations have amassed a spectacular arsenal of terror weapons that can reach every part of Israel. What many do not realize is that if these terror organizations do what they do best -kill civilians- successfully, Israel will be forced to step back from its usual highly measured a restrained approach to battle. Perhaps replicating what NATO and all other countries do on regularly -put their Israeli civilians and soldiers first. This would necessitate the complete elimination of Hezbollah, Hamas, and countless human shields.

Who knows how Erdogan-dominated Turkey would react?

Therefore.

Israel should make it clear that the Arabs -who will benefit greatly from such an attack- that Israel will not be both their whipping boy and their savior.

Israel should attempt to gain concessions from the Arab nations. Recognition may be a pipe-dream, but putting pressure on Hamas, the PLO/PA, for peace- real peace- is a legitimate option. Also, written guarantees to completely halt all anti-Semitic anti-Israel incitement (thus blood libels/organ harvesting, kill the Zionists, bad, criticism, like that found in the New York Times, ok, for more on this please see post “http://factoru.blogspot.com/2010/04/i-have-no-problem-with-jews-its-just.html) that is regularly displayed and taught in all Middle-Eastern Arab nations (check out memriTV). Finally, the establishment of direct economic ties which is a prerequisite for Middle-Eastern development and eventual peace.

Of course the Saudis may not agree to such concessions, which is why Israel needs the Obama administration to wake up and reassert America’s rightful role as the only great AND just power in the universe. Many Americans, the pragmatic ones anyway, see the opportunity here, we should not overlook it. Besides, as in the past, Israel will be on the front line defending Western interests. But America needs to do its part.

Hopefully the above steps if taken and carried out may actually turn the Iranian crises, into a pivotal moment in history that could prevent another Iran from arising in the Middle-East.

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Has 60 Years of Israeli-Turkish Ties Died in a Hale of Provocation and Bullets?

In many discussion, a good friend (who happens to be Turkish, and frankly makes all Turkey look good) and I have often discussed Israel-Turkish ties since Davos.

We have always recognized that an Israeli-Turkish alliance, had great benefits. As of yesterday Israel and Turkey had over 20 billion dollars in deals.

Now the question is not only whether these strong strategic/economic ties will weather this violent storm, but also whether this is a new development, or just a keystone event in a larger progression?

In other words, despite my great respect for modern Turkey and the Ottoman empires contributions to larger society, I can not help but feel that this recent, monumental, error by the Israeli government, only accelerated a trend that has been evident since Davos (for more on this please see post "Erdogan and Turkey: are the Israelis right, has Ataturk’s legacy failed Turkey").

The very fact that Turkey gave its tacit support for a flotilla that was bent on causing a provocation, reflects this larger trend.

Some in Turkey and Israel concede, that Turkey and Israel will both lose if the relationship is ended. Yet no one in Turkey raised the question on May 30 as to whether it served Turkey and the regions interest for this Turkish dominated flotilla to move ahead. Is it because Turkey has been silenced by Erdogan or because Erdogan speaks for Turkey?

I don't know.

At the same time I feel that it is only after such a tragic event that the nature of a nation-state can be discerned. It will only be a matter of time before we see if the ties will be truly cut, and what the Turkish-Israeli relationship really means.

Meanwhile I feel strangely confident. I say this only after speaking with my well educated friend and reading Hurriyet online (a Turkish English daily). I feel encouraged by the fact that many Turkish people remain pragmatic and rational. After 9 people were killed while NOT launching rockets, what more can any Jew, American, or Israeli ask of the Turkish people?

PS

There are "rumors" that more Turkish sponsored Flotillas are going to launched! I don't think this serves anyones interests.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Erdogan and Turkey: Are the Israelis right and has Ataturks legacy failed?

Israel attempt to bolster its relationship with Turkey with a February transfer of Herons (one of the most advanced Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) systems) to Turkey, had failed. This is due in no small part to Turkeys rhetoric prone Prime Minister Recap Erdogan, who is fixated on destroying the Israeli-Turkish relations.

The Israeli-Turkish relationship has always been emotionless, uncaring, and uneasy. At the same time there has been undeniable strategic partnership since Turkey was the first Muslim country to recognize Israel, in 1949. The relationship has paid off. Turkey has gained entrance into NATO, and has the 5th largest, and very well equipped, military on earth.

However this April’s revelation that Israel rejected Turkeys request for the Barack 8, a 360 degree naval defense shield, is a tangible indicator that Erdogans rhetoric driven campaign against Israel is succeeding. Israel, and its research partner India, fear Turkey will transfer advanced technologies to belligerent nations like Pakistan and Iran. The fact that Turkey is moving away from its historical relationship with Israel was affirmed when they pulled out of a NATO exercise due to the participation of the Israeli Air Force (AIF). If Turkey had not then staged military exercises with its neighbor Syria, and openly declared that it will not stand by if Israel launches an attack on Syria or Iran, the former move could have seen as simply a protest of the Gaza war of 2008.

The bottom line is that Erdogan has been rather aggressive and successful in his attempt to separate Turley and Israel. But why?

Unless Erdogan is looking for war, Erdogans effort to elevate Turkey to the regional power will have include the collaboration of Israel. Clearly Erdogan is not furthering that goal, at least not through peaceful means. Likewise, the view that Erdogans need to bash Israel to gain the trust of the Arab world is untenable. Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan all work closely with Israel and would certainly accept Turkey into their alliance against Iran.

Instead Erdogan has aligned Turkey with the minority alliance in the region Syria-Iran-Hamas-Hezbollah. This too is confusing considering that Iran is aiming for regional hegemony, by pursuing nuclear weapons, weapons that would essentially obviate Turkey’s powerful, but un-nuclear military. Is Turkey submitting to Iran!

From a regional perspective it is difficult to defend Erdogans policies towards Israel. Then again that may be the key to understanding Erdogan – his aims are domestic not regional.

Over the last two years Turkey has seen two alleged coup attempts by the military, or so the AK, Erdogans Islamist-leaning party, would have you believe. The first in 2008 ostensibly was executed by the ultranationalist gang, "Ergenekon,” That aborted coup resulted in 400 arrests and zero known convictions ( Interestingly, the left/liberal-leaning new paper, Taraf, broke the story (http://www.csmonitor.com) and later alleged that the Israeli foreign intelligence unit, Mossad, was behind the attempt. The evidence rings of blood-libel proportions –a sack with an Israeli flag and Mossad memorabilia (?!) was found in a conspirators home. The left/Islamic relationship in secular countries is an established phenomenon; suffice to say it requires a separate analysis).

The second coup occurred in 2010 and included the arrest of 7 high ranking military officers, including the three former heads of the navy, air force, and Special Forces, along with 50 others.

For those that are unfamiliar with the modern Turkish system, this is part of the Turkish political process. The Turkish secular revivalist, and founder of the Modern Turkish state, Mustafa Kemal Pasha Ataturk, established a system whereas the military in Turkey is empowered to ensure the secular nature of Turkey –a check on the government if you will. Since 1945 there have been 3 major coups conducted by the military in 1961, 1970, 1980.

Some explain Erdogans attack as an attempt to subdue the military which impedes Turkey’s aspirations in the international community -and has often been pointed to as a major barrier to Turkey’s acceptance into the EU. At the same time Erdogan has repudiated Turkeys desire to join the EU, and his recent alliances with Syria and Iran do nothing to further Turkey’s acceptance into the EU.

What is infinitely clear is that whether the military coups were fabricated or real, the military and Erdogan perceive each other as a threat.

Were it not for this week’s resignation of Turkey’s long standing leader of the secular Republicans People Party, Deniz Baykal, over an alleged sex scandal, the above discussion would do little more than affirm the belief that Turkey is in the midst of a struggle over its nature Ataturk/secular/military or religious/ Muslim/Erdogan. Yet taken as a whole it seems that Erdogan is keen on taking complete power or at least minimizing all his opponents.

Placed in this light, Erdogans attack on Israel is really an attack on the two major forces of opposition in Turkey, the military and the secular parties. To be fair both of these groups are not friends of Israel, but they do have close ties with Israel and are actually supported by Israel. In other words Israel is not stupid; it did not transfer huran UAV’s because they trusted Erdogan. They did so because it would strengthen the hand of the secular/military in Turkey, who can claim “look it pays to be secular, it pays to ally with Israel”. Moreover, it indicates that Israel still believed that Turkey’s staunchly secular military would be able to reassert themselves against Erdogans political onslaught. After the latest failed coup, Israel’s decision not to provide further military hardware reflects Israel’s conclusion that the Turkish secular/military alliance has faltered (fatally ?).

Only a secular Turkey could ally itself with Israel, and Erdogan seeks to undermine his secular opponents in any way possible. By fostering anti-Israel sentiments in Turkey, Erdogan is also engendering negative attitudes towards Israel’s perceived allies within Turkey –the secular/military. Furthermore Turkey relationship with Israel is predicated on a simple trade, advanced military hardware, for political allegiance. But now that Israel refuses to give any more advanced weapons to Turkey the military in Turkey is further delegitimized. After all it was the military that pushed an alliance with Israel, but what has it done for Turkey, Israel won’t even provide weapons!

This also explains Erdogans alliance with Iran. If he is going to lose one nuclear regional power and supporter of his military he needs to trade it for another regionally and nuclear strong ally. Since Erdogan is focused on domestic hegemony, for the moment, his ire aimed at the larger barrier to that goal -Israel.

Erdogan is savvy politician and employing exceptional stratagem. The mistake of the observer was to accept it as a given that Erdogans main focus was regional, and that Israel was the ends of his strategy. In fact Israel is but one piece, one means, to Erdogan ends -national subjugation to his will.

But what are Erdogans national aims, and are the Israelis right, has Ataturk’s legacy failed Turkey?

Monday, January 18, 2010

Turkey and Israel: Two perspectives (part 1)

They say it started in Davos when the Turkish prime minister Recyap Erdogan stormed off the public stage after he was prevented from continuing his criticism of Israel's operation cast lead. Others argue that it was the collapse of Syrian-Israeli peace talks spearheaded by Turkey. Turkey claims,that Israel's attack on Gaza led to the collapse of Syrian-Israeli negotiations. This was compounded by what many considered to be an insult, considering that Erdogan was not informed by Israel that they were about to respond to 3 years of mortar attacks from Gaza. Furthermore, Erdogan claims he was assured by the Israeli that no attack was forthcoming. But my Turkish friends tell me it is part of a larger regional strategy begun before Erdogan Islamic-leaning Justice and Development Party (AK) came to power.

So I decided to talk to some of my more informed Turkish friends to gain some perspective.
The following is a very rough transcript of our conversations.

Me: What is going on with Turkish Israeli relations?

Friend: You mean the TV shows?

Me: Yeah. Valley of the Wolves and that other one that came out a couple of months ago, their so stereotypical and fictitious.

Friend: It's not like the government sponsored these shows.

Me: Yeah but the government would never have allowed them to be shown two years ago.

Friend:I hear you it is unnecessary.

Me: Hey don't get me wrong I'm all for complete freedom, but this reflects a deeper shift in the Turkish-Israeli relationship.

Freind: Yeah, Turkey wants to redevelop its regional dominance. It's overtures to Iran,agreement with Armenia, softening of restrictions on the border with Syria, and meetings with Lebanon are all part of the same strategy pushing Erdogan to be so critical of Israel, both formally and informally, such as Turkish TV.

Me: That I understand, but does Turkey really want to give up its strategic partnership with Israel? After all Israel is constantly providing Turkey with military hardware and assistance. Remember the 2006 PPK conflict, Israel provided key intelligence to Turkey. Now Israel is selling 10 of the most advanced UAV's in the world to Turkey.

Friend: Still, many in Turkey remember when the Mossad was providing material support for the Kurds against Turkey.

Me: That's Israel. Yet I think they tried to make up for that by sending medical and search and rescue teams to Turkey after that earthquake.

Friend: That was important, but expected. Remember Turkey has a long history of protecting its Jewish minority.

Me: No question about it. Following the Christian expulsion of Jews from Spain in 1492 and the subsequent explosion from Portugal, Turkey accepted the Jews,and has treated them relatively well, for close to 5 centuries.

Me: The bottom line is that Erdogan has taken every opportunity to bash Israel. That "admonition" to Turkish students that "they should learn from Jews how to make money", and his public statement, to President Omar al-Bashir of Sudan, that he didn't believe the ICC's (international criminal court) indictment to be true because, "Muslims cant commit genocide", are not helpful to regional dialogue.
Don't get me wrong Ayalon's treatment of the Turkish ambassador, placing him on a lower couch and admonishing him publicly, was plain stupidity.

Friend: Yeah what was that about?

Me: That was an immature explosion following months of passive aggressive behavior on the part of Israel. What Israel should have done was challenge Erdogan following specific instances of, what Israel deemed, abuse. Not wait and then act impulsively.

Friend: Agreed. Why can't Turkey, Israel, and Iran just establish a non-Arab alliance?

Me: Yeah right.

Friend: I know.

Me: Does Turkey see Israel as standing in their way of a Turkish dominated Middle East? If so Iran seems to be the bigger threat to that hegemony?

Friend: I think Turkey sees Iran as the other power broker in the Middle East. Besides, Turkey just completed a very successful summit with Russia. As Turkey moves away from their bid to join the EU it makes sense that they are reorienting towards
Russia, another quasi-ally of Iran.

Me: Yet Turkey is part of NATO, how does that jive with a Turkey-Russian-Iranian pact?